Lucy Cat Food Review

Lucy Pet Products makes limited-ingredient dry and wet cat foods, plus lickable treats, with sales supporting the Lucy Pet Foundation. It is a decent mid-priced option for cats that do well on simple recipes, but the dry foods are fairly high in carbohydrates and some cats simply refuse it.

Chewy Online Pet Supplies


35% Off at Chewy.com

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

What Lucy Pet makes for cats

  • Dry food: two limited-ingredient recipes, Chicken, Brown Rice and Pumpkin (with grains) and Salmon, Pumpkin and Quinoa (grain-free).
  • Wet food (Kettle Creations): gravy recipes in chicken, chicken and duck, sardine and tuna, and salmon and chicken flavors.
  • Lickable treats: small tubes in flavors such as chicken and duck or sardine and tuna.

Recipes and availability change, so check the current label and the manufacturer’s site before you buy.

Ingredients and what stands out

The proteins come from chicken, chicken meal, turkey meal, salmon, duck, tuna or sardine depending on the recipe. The dry foods use animal fats such as chicken fat and fish oil and include a prebiotic fiber blend. They are also relatively high in carbohydrates, and the salmon recipe leans on peas and chickpeas. Cats are obligate carnivores, so many owners prefer a food with less starch and more meat-based protein. The wet recipes include pumpkin and most include brown rice, and some use plant oils or gums for texture. Guar gum can loosen stools in a few sensitive cats.

Where it is made and safety record

Lucy Pet foods are produced by Breeder’s Choice Pet Foods in Westlake Village, California. Cats.com’s 2026 review found no known recalls, but recall history can change, so check the FDA’s recall list if you want the latest status.

Price

Based on that same review, wet food runs about 71 cents an ounce when bought direct and the 10-pound dry bag works out around 25 cents an ounce. That is more than discount brands. If budget is your main concern, the premium is hard to justify unless you value the foundation’s work.

Pros and cons

  • Pros: mostly animal-based protein and fat in the dry foods, small easy-to-eat kibble, high-moisture wet food, check the ingredient panel of the exact recipe you buy for artificial colors, and part of sales supports spay and neuter work.
  • Cons: high carbohydrates in the dry foods, plant-based thickeners in the wet foods, premium pricing, and some owners report cats turning it down or batch-to-batch texture changes.

Who it suits

Lucy Pet is worth trying for healthy adult cats that tolerate simple recipes, especially if you can buy it locally in small amounts first. It is not a substitute for a veterinary diet. Cats with kidney disease, urinary problems, diabetes or food allergies need a food chosen with your vet, such as the options in our Royal Canin urinary care review.

For comparison, see our guides to the best cat pouch food, Sheba wet cat food and choosing food for kittens.

Bottom Line

Lucy Pet cat food is a reasonable limited-ingredient choice with a good safety record, but it is not outstanding for the price and the dry recipes are carb-heavy. Buy a small bag or a few cans first, transition over 7 to 10 days, and talk to your vet if your cat has any health condition. This article is general information, not veterinary advice.